News, opinion and resources for the North West media industry Subscribe to our RSS feed
Front Page | Jobs | News | How-Do TV | Features | Comment | Rumours | How do they do | How did they do | Blogs | About | Links | Login | MarketPlace
NEWS BY SECTOR | Publishing | Broadcasting | Marketing Services | Digital Media | Other Media | The Wrap | Polls | How-Do Awards | How-Do Events

Penniless Salford Star on hold, as Kingston slams LIFE | Print |  Email to a friend
Monday, 24 November 2008

Community magazine, and How-Do award winner, The Salford Star has been forced to cancel its Christmas edition due to a lack of funds. However, Stephen Kingston, the editor and founder of the title, has made clear to How-Do that “there’s no way that the title’s dead.”
Community magazine, and How-Do award winner, The Salford Star has been forced to cancel its Christmas edition due to a lack of funds. However, Stephen Kingston, the editor and founder of the title, has made clear to How-Do that “there’s no way that the title’s dead.”

“I’ll stack shelves in Tesco to get the money to print it if I have to,” he told us.

In a candid and typically passionate interview, Kingston admitted that the magazine was effectively “penniless” but then explained that that was normal operating procedure for the Star.

Christmas coming late this year

“We just don’t have the money to print the Christmas issue,” he stated, “but then it’s always a struggle.

Image
Double trouble, in terms of print cost
“We usually get the advertisers to pay up front to fund the print run, but this time I had to basically hock the advertising for this issue to pay for the summer edition, which was a double issue.

“But we will get it out eventually, even if we have to raise ten quid at a time. It might be at the end of January, it might be February… but then we’re always late anyway,” he laughed.

Kingston strongly rebuked any suggestion that this could be the end of the line for the Star, imparting that he and his band of community volunteers – numbering around 100 in total – are totally committed to its future.

“There’s been some suggestions about changing the format to a newspaper, or online, and saving money. But I’m against that.

“The Star has a glossy format and I think Salford deserves that kind of quality.

“As far as just putting it online,” he continued, “that might work for something like How-Do, but it wouldn’t work for us."

Community first

“We want pensioners to read it, little kids to pick it up – we want to get this magazine into people’s hands, get it out there and into the community.

Image
Community spirit
“You also have to remember that we’re going into some of the most deprived areas in Europe, let alone in England. Not everyone has access to the internet, in fact it’s only 20% of the people in Salford.

“This is a community title, so it has to be relevant for that community.”

In terms of raising the funds to continue, Kingston sees only one realistic revenue stream (apart from Tesco’s) where he can turn – advertising.

The problem is, he says, there’s no dedicated advertising sales person for the title (“volunteers are very welcome”), there’s not a great deal of businesses actually in Salford that have the means to advertise and – regular How-Do’ers won’t be surprised to hear – the council aren’t really all that keen to stick their own ads in there.

“We’re a community magazine, we need to be publicly funded,” he stressed.

LIFE's a bitch

“But we can’t get funding – our application for devolved funding last year was ripped up by the council – and meanwhile they can award themselves £175k for their own propaganda sheet.

Image
Kingston doesn't get LIFE
“It’s the lack of equality of funding that gets me. It’s simply not fair.”

Talk of the Council’s LIFE plans is like a red rag to the bullshit free Kingston, who goes on at blunt yet impassioned length about the advertising revenues (he says about £100k) that will now be taken away from the local press (“not from us though, we’ve never seen a cent”) and the jobs that will be affected as a result.

“It’s bonkers, just bonkers,” is the way he finally, breathlessly sums it up.

As for the Star itself, it will shine again, he stresses and re-stresses, but it will also have to sit in alongside his freelance journalism – “I’ve got to live too you know” – although hopefully not a job at Tesco’s.

“We have something special here,’ Kingston concluded.

“The demand always outstrips the supply – I mean we’d double the print run if we could - and there are an army of local volunteers that get involved because this is their magazine.

“It’s important. And it has a future. It’s a genuine community project for a genuine community.

“Simple as that.”

www.salfordstar.com

 

Something to add? Then leave a comment below or email us now.


Did you enjoy this article? Please share it!
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!


Sponsored links:




  Comments (16)
RSS comments
 1 By Realist, on 24-11-2008 10:35
The Star is to be commended on many, many fronts - but it can't go on like this without public funding (which it deserves, but probably won't get as it's way too much of a loose cannon). 
 
Stephen you may have to compromise somewhere down the line if you're ever going to get public money. Sad, but true. 
 
Good luck.
 2 By ali (salford resident), on 24-11-2008 12:10
This is very sad. The Star needs support. It is a great read and contains REAL news not like the PR nonsense we are submitted to by regional, national and international mainstream media on a daily basis. Salford needs it and other areas of the UK need their own Star. Potential advertisers give it some thought, please!
 3 By Fish, on 24-11-2008 12:45
It is precisely because John Merry and his Crazy gang can give their own publication £175K from Council Tax payers Pockets that Salford Star exists. 
 
Stephen must not compromise.  
 
Salford people like Russell Watson/Robert Powell/Coronation Street & Hollyoaks stars/ Hooky & Bernard Sumner should get their hands in their pockets and bail out The Shining Star.  
 
An award winning magazine which feeds the community should be fed by that community.
 4 By Clurbur, on 27-11-2008 00:41
After spending the day at the first ever Timber in Construction conference, delegates sat down for the awards dinner.  
 
I completely agree Fish... it would be a travesty if the Star compromised on content.  
 
This magazine is a fantastic read... we should start a petition...
 5 By Brian (Salford resident), on 26-11-2008 22:30
The Star, just like Life is actually vanity publishing albeit much better quality. The difference is that the council does have an audience and as such some advertising potential. It is very difficult looking at The Star to then identify a potential advertiser or few. Lets face it, all commercial mags and newspapers are designed to sell ads first and then inform. The Star unfortunately wants to do the opposite in a tightening market .......
 6 By Steve Saggores, on 27-11-2008 11:21
Britain's best community magazine (Official: How Do award winner) existing in the constituency of the serving Minster for Communities. Come on Hazel open up one of your funding pots for Salford's Star! 
 
We have one of the most creative communities in our city- Uni of Salford - come on Professor Bigwig - your Uni's future students read and feature in the Star. Forget losing a few quid in Icelandic Banks - get some money into your local area. Support Stephen and the Salford Star!
 7 By Stephen Kingston website, on 27-11-2008 12:32
Got to reply to Brian and others...The Salford Star does have a massive audience in the city, and we just can't print enough mags to keep up with demand. 
 
Our potential advertisers are organisations like Salford Council, the Police, the PCT and all those `arms length' leisure and social housing companies; public and semi public organisations that are supposed to connect with so-called `difficult to reach' people...None of these has ever advertised with us - maybe it's got something to do with the fact that we have been known (once or twice) to criticise the Council. You decide. 
 
As far as running the mag for the benefit of advertisers...this will never happen at 
the Salford Star. That's why people tend to trust us. And, besides, there's enough of that already in the media. We'll never compromise just to get advertisers or funding, otherwise there's no point in doing it. Compromise with the truth?  
 
What are journalists for? To big up property developers, celebs and crap councils? We'd rather shut the Star down.  
 
In some countries they shoot journalists and blow up their offices. Here we're dealing with censorship through economics.
 8 By Sweaty Betty, on 28-11-2008 00:10
Totally well said. Keep on going Stephen. At least you are honestly holding your head above the firing line. There is always a way.
 9 By realist, on 01-12-2008 13:13
Stephen it's all very well complaining that none of the public bodies or semi-public companies in Salford have approached you for advertising, but frankly you can't sit on your throne and expect organisations to come and demand the privilege of paying you for advertising! You have to proactively court it and the fact that you have a free mag that doesn't have anyone doing ad sales means you're doomed before you begin. If you get your act together and get someone with a sales background to actually go out to the likes of the police and social housing organisations and ask them for advertising, you might have a fighting chance.
 10 By stephen kingston website, on 03-12-2008 08:10
Hi realist 
 
Couldn't agree more - just can't find anyone to do it, cos we can only pay commission - do you want a job with the Salford Star??? Or if anyone else is reading this please get in touch - step right this way for the hardest job in the world...roll up, roll up!
 11 By starman, on 03-12-2008 09:14
Hi Steve, how about asking Ten Alps if can outsource advertising to them so that you can focus on editorial? They do a good job for Private Eye which has a similar remit.
 12 By Realitycheck, on 03-12-2008 09:28
Why not take the mag to Dragons' Den? You've as much chance getting money from them as the government.
 13 By stephen kingston website, on 03-12-2008 10:26
Hi Starman - been there, done that - I think they ran away screaming at the prospect! 
 
Reality - sorry but I'm not a performing clown (no matter what certain people might say!) - also there's no profit to be made - we're a non-profit company. The Salford Star has got to be publicly funded, or at least a part of it. We cover 50% of the print costs already through ads.  
Just need a big brand that wants to be associated with freedom of expression, truth, ethics and stuff like that - not many about!
 14 By Mulls, on 12-12-2008 00:25
I heartily commend the Star and everything it stands for. However I really would consider switching - even on a temporary basis - to a newspaper format. Surely the crucial thing is to keep publishing and you wouldn't have to compromise on the quality of what matters - the writing. The costs of printing a newspaper are around a third of an A4 magazine and surely it would make sense in the short term.  
I do know of some cases where charities and other groups have made contributions to community publications in return for the publication giving them a page or two for their newsletter. It works out cheaper for them than sending out newsletters and helps the community publication keep going. 
Whatever happens, you deserve to keep going.
 15 By charity, on 12-12-2008 10:25
There are lots of bodies such as Surestarts which get central govt cash which advertise in yellow pages, but would probably get more focused adverts in the Star. There are Surestarts in Swinton and probably around the city. Also childminding and nursery groups who could buy ads. Also local cafes. You might have to sell small spaces rather than display but hey, every little helps. 
And what about some of the creative industries around Salford and doesn't the University have a promotional budget? 
And isn't Granada spiritually based in Salford and aren't they community-spirited and big-hearted? (perhaps not!)
 16 By Loggedoff, on 12-12-2008 11:40
Some good ideas flowing here.  
Also how about using the mag to help promote Salford Star Live Events. With all the good will around why not tap into it with live Salford based events? 
The events could make the money to keep the mag going and fit in with the community spirit side of things. 
Also the volunteer network could provide much of the staffing. Salford University runs event management courses and there will be lots of semi-pro volunteers available there who are yearning for experience, esp in culture and music events. The Uni would be keen as it helps them in their community outreach work.

Add your comment
Name
Email (optional)
Website (optional)
Comment

Email me when someone else comments
Anti-spam question (required): 5 + 8 =

 
< Previous story   Next story >


Online Marketing Manchester
Today's other news
Pets At Home appoints AWA to help drive its online activities
Designate releases Blackpool The Movie for LBTB
Spoken-Image delivers video solution for NHS Gloucestershire
Remedia claims largest advertising banner in Manchester
BBC apologises for using photo of slain policeman on the 6 o'clock news
True North creates new identity for Queer Up North
Manchester United signs sponsorship deal with MTN of South Africa
Baxter to leave Bell Pottinger in search of a new career change
How-Do weekly Wrap - 19 March 2010 - Nadia Kassas
Creative Concern develops brand for Brockholes development
New deputy programme director at Key 103
Blackpool Gazette and Herald journalists step up industrial action
Multimillion pound internet facility to open near MediaCityUK
Fluid Creativity mops up Christy Towels deal
Title Role signs first look deal with Outright Distribution
Sharp Project gets new £6.3m grant
 
 
 How-Do Events - click here    How-Do Events - click here
 
 
 
Most read in the last three days
Channel M to move to Salford and plans new productions
Launch of the inaugural Marketing Society Northern Awards
Blackpool Gazette and Herald journalists step up industrial action
Multimillion pound internet facility to open near MediaCityUK
Manchester United signs sponsorship deal with MTN of South Africa
Fluid Creativity mops up Christy Towels deal
Edge Hill spikes journalism course
Sharp Project gets new £6.3m grant
BBC rejects Guardian report that 5 Live move is delayed
BBC apologises for using photo of slain policeman on the 6 o'clock news
Featured articles
The most comprehensive ever review and assessment of the top communicators and marketers working in public services in the North West: the Public Sector 100. READ
Media 100
The North West’s top marketing folk who collectively control marketing expenditure in excess of £500m and whose endeavours help sustain tens of thousands of jobs. READ
2009media100 The full listing of How-Do's Media 100. The 2009 list in its entirety, offers the definitive compilation of the most influential and powerful media, creative and digital folk based in the North West. READ
 
Contact us now
The How-Do poll
How can traditional publishing firms make money online?
 
Latest comments
Hic hack: ...and if I did "piss on [my] chips for a job in journalism later on," for ... READ
Captain Chaos: By Channel M launch on Freewire t website, on 21-03-2010 10:52 launch on c... READ
Mike Hunt: I'm also with Mike Flex, Mike Stand, Mike Roffone and Watcher. GMG are slip... READ
Mike Stand: I'mwith Mike Flex, Mike Roffone and Watcher too. GMG has pulled a flanker.J... READ
grey scale ?: Can confirm that Mich was carried in a blaze of of pantone colour to Handel... READ
A. Farnell: It's a shit story anyway. ...and if I did "piss on [my] chips for a job ... READ
How-Do RSS/Twitter

Track How-Do headlines in your RSS reader:

RSS feed

View all of our feeds.

Follow How-Do on Twitter:

How-Do Twitter






Front Page | Jobs | News | How-Do TV | Features | Comment | Rumours | How do they do | How did they do | Blogs | About | Links | Login | MarketPlace
NEWS BY SECTOR | Publishing | Broadcasting | Marketing Services | Digital Media | Other Media | The Wrap | Polls | How-Do Awards | How-Do Events
 
UKFast - managed dedicated server specialist