News, opinion and resources for the North West media industry Subscribe to our RSS feed
Front Page | How-Do TV | News | Jobs | Features | Comment | Rumours | How do they do | How did they do | Expertise | Blogs | Education | About | Login
NEWS BY SECTOR | Publishing | Broadcasting | Marketing Services | Digital Media | Other Media | The Wrap | Polls | How-Do Awards

Hemisphere reacts to charges of plagiarism dogging new Oldham brand | Print |  Email to a friend
Friday, 18 April 2008
Design agency Hemisphere has taken the step of releasing a statement to How-Do in an effort to explain the in-depth thought and creative processes that were employed in the crafting of their (seemingly controversial) new brand for Oldham.
Design agency Hemisphere has taken the step of releasing a statement to How-Do in an effort to explain the in-depth thought and creative processes that were employed in the crafting of its (seemingly controversial) new brand for Oldham.

Postings on the How-Do comment board have called into question the agency’s inspiration for the brand, with several individuals suggesting that the marque bears an uncanny resemblance to Transport for London’s Oyster Card branding and the Congestion Charge symbol.

In a move to rebuke these claims, and give How-Do readers a chance to look under the surface of the ‘O’ identity, Sue Vanden from Hemisphere released the following statement.

We have printed it here in full.

Image
What do you think?
Sue Vanden:

“The Oldham brand strategy was developed after a wide-ranging process of research and consultation and one of the most important issues it highlighted was the perceived fractured nature of the local community. 

One of the key objectives of the resulting visual identity brief was therefore to help create a sense of unity for the town, as well as communicating its distinctive mix of urban and rural landscapes.

The identity scheme consists of a signature colour, a specific font, a graphic ‘badge’ and a tone of voice that is based around phrases that use the word ‘one’.

Image
Totally different?
The graphic badge – or logo - incorporates an O for some fundamental reasons – the circle is a symbol of unity, O is the first letter of the name of the town, and the same white O is also used as a consistent device in all the various text lines that are used to communicate to different audiences.

The styling of the graphic badge is also a subtle reference to Oldham’s historic symbol, an owl, with the proportions of the circle akin to an owl’s eye and the 3 dimensional element showing the reflection of landscape.

Oldham’s new identity is not just a logo in isolation, but rather a holistic scheme that has a resonance with the heritage of the area whilst also articulating the need for it to present itself and act as one place.

Image
Or too similar?
Like Oldham, it is down to earth and practical, strong but not flamboyant and it meets head-on a very specific and detailed brief.

Hemisphere was appointed to create the new brand identity for Oldham based on our track record of producing successful branding schemes for Salford and Bolton. 

Place brands by definition should not be judged on the basis of a visual alone but on the cultural and perceptual change they create in the place themselves over a period of time.

As Salford and Bolton have shown, if you can be consistent about what you do, what you say and how you represent yourself, then you can make a significant difference to your reputation.”

www.hemispheredmc.com

 

Something to add? Then leave a comment below or email us now.


Did you enjoy this article? Please share it!
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!


Sponsored links:




  Comments (23)
RSS comments
 1 By Charlie Daily, on 18-04-2008 10:08
Nice try Sue, that probably took longer than it took to rip off the logo. 
 
Design finalised on a Friday? Just before lunch?
 2 By Hugga Huddy, on 18-04-2008 10:10
If you look on the TFL homepage (www.tfl.gov.uk), the TFL brands can be seen side-by-side. I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt after reading the statement but the similarities are too marked for this to be a coincidence.  
 
As I mentioned earlier, I believe the thought process in creating the Oldham logo was very simple. 
 
You wanted to make comparisons with a successful, vibrant city; You thought of London; You visited their most trafficked website; and then appropriated two of the strongest brands which are associated with that city.  
 
I’m pretty sure the marketing departments of TFL and Transys will think exactly the same. 
 
If this re-brand was done with private funds, I wouldn’t care how the logo was created. But why should the public purse pay for copied work?
 3 By Get a grip, on 18-04-2008 10:29
You honestly believe that an agency would take a very high profile job in the public domain and rip off another very high profile job in the public domain to find the solution? 
 
That my friend is a ridiculous notion. 
 
This is not copied, it is similar. That's all... it happens sometimes.
 4 By target, on 18-04-2008 10:43
if you were doing a 'target' logo, wouldn't you at least google 'target' and see what comes up - just to make sure you weren't doing something that someone else had done? http://www.target.com/
 5 By Davved, on 18-04-2008 10:45
All seems like a bit like a witch hunt to me, with hidden aliases instead of pitch forks.  
 
I expect next week something else will come along for the cowards who abuse this open forum to attack. 
 
It baffles me how these people throwing faceless accusations around really cannot see how the creative process arrived at the resultant marque. 
 
The work isn't rocket science, but it's for a local authority with many thorny issues - so it's hardly going to on the cutting edge is it? By all means have an opinion, but an educated one please... 
 
Oh, and it really is getting quite boring now - trotting out the old 'taxpayers money' line. 
 
I picked up a postcard then other week with an illiustration and funny caption, it read:  
 
Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups. 
 
I'm not bothering with this site anymore. 
Davved 
 
Ps. I'm now awaiting another seriously well educated insult from Charlie boy...what a fine wordsmith he is.
 6 By Mike G, on 18-04-2008 10:57
Davved, you’ve just summed up what we all guessed. Hemisphere thought people were too stupid to suss what you were doing. This is a rip-off and you’ve been busted!
 7 By Get a grip, on 18-04-2008 10:59
I agree with Davved on most points. 
 
There's jealously at work here and axes to grind re the use of public funds. 
 
That said - have a look at that Target website with their registered trademark. 
 
There's a much bigger problem there than there is with the London logos. 
 
A much bigger one.
 8 By outraged of Tunbridge Wells website, on 18-04-2008 11:04
I'm outraged 
 
Look 
 
http://www.raf.mod.uk/ 
 
This is clearly a rip off of the RAF logo. As is the one for Target the Congestion Charge logo and many others. 
 
Or perhaps NOT. 
 
Go away you pointless little people and take your silly views with you. 
 
Well done Oldham it looks great.
 9 By Emma, on 18-04-2008 11:27
The producers of the Oldham logo don’t appear to be au fait with IP law. The Oldham brand and the CC and Oyster brands are similar logos (which are at present) strongly associated with specific geographical locations.  
 
It’s not like a soft drink company having a similar logo to a construction company. The Oldham brand does appear to have been heavily influenced by the TFL brands.  
 
I’m not a betting person, but I sure once the posters are up and the signs/livery are painted, lawyers will rear their ugly heads.
 10 By outraged of Tunbridge Wells website, on 18-04-2008 13:11
Emma 
 
You haven't got a clue what you are talking about have you? 
 
Lawyers rearing their ugly heads just like stupid ill informed people who make pointless ill educated comments on place branding in places they clearly don't live or have any connection to. 
 
Did you pitch for it and not win? 
 
or any other form of sour fruit?
 11 By O-bvious, O-ld-fashioned, O-ve, on 18-04-2008 13:11
Hemisphere's thought process:  
1. Oldham begins with an O  
2. An O is a circle  
3. Eureka! let's design a circle 
4. Add a bright colour, (Somerfield/Metrolink/Heinz Baked Beanz) will do. Add Photoshop shine filter No. 3. Add some badly-set ugly dated font.  
5. Bingo!  
 
Oldham needs a new look and usually Hemisphere's work is first class, but obviously this time they let a junior designer work on it. What a disappointment.
 12 By JW, on 18-04-2008 13:40
Calling people stupid and ill educated (sic) isn’t going to hide what Hemisphere has done. This has exposed a screamingly obvious case of plagiarism, that’s been masked with florid PR-babble. A child could see what you’ve done.
 13 By who cares, on 18-04-2008 13:40
In reference to the person who said a 'junior designer' must have done it, what people forget is that you can present the most outstanding design you've ever done, but if the people approving it are quite old fashioned and not design savvy, it gets diluted. What a great PR campaign to launch the new brand though, negative or positive, it's got people talking.
 14 By BC, on 18-04-2008 14:25
On this forum, anyone who comments without giving their email address is obviously a coward as their comments are wholly unaccountable.  
 
I will state now I have a connection with Oldham, but nothing to do with the new Oldham identity.  
 
I think the accusations of plagiarism are weak and at best wholly unfounded. I challenge anyone to find another local authority/area of the UK, or the world for that matter, that has an identity anywhere near this. IP law applies where there is brand confusion created by similar marks. No one could possibly think: "I am going to buy my congestion charge, oh damn I have accidentally bought Oldham thinking it was my congestion charge." Similarly if the congestion charge symbol and Oyster card symbols are so similar how do they both co-exist in the TfL brand? Do visitors to London accidentally purchase an Oster card thinking they are paying for their congestion charge - NO, they don't because they posses a brain capable of distinguishing the difference. I have never bought a Beatles album thinking it was an iPod.  
 
The big question that has to be asked: is it an improvement on Oldham's previous identity? - the answer has to be yes!  
 
Oldham does need a new fresh identity to harmonise the communities that comprise it as well as reinvigorating investment and opportunities.  
 
I think the design produced by Hemisphere is carefully considered and well executed. Congratulations to Hemisphere and to Oldham for taking this step, it's a pity more places and local authorities in the UK aren't as forward-looking in embracing good design.  
 
The clichéd "waste of money" argument has reared its head again - it's always the same and indicative of the lack of value placed on design in Britain which is ironic because the design industry is an incredibly important part of the UK's economy and one of the few areas of 'manufacturing' still thriving and growing. When the BBC rebranded in 1996 the cry of "How much for three squares and three letters?" was bandied about the red-tops, but in 2008, 12 years on the BBC logo is still going strong and a leading worldwide identity mark.  
 
Unfortunately the discontented minority often shouts the loudest to the detriment of the common good. Well, if you are shouting at least have the courage of your convictions by including an email address.
 15 By outraged of Tunbridge Wells website, on 18-04-2008 14:55
Imagine my surprise the other day when i tried to come to Oldham and accidentally joined the RAF! 
 
Anyway, i'm getting to see the world and meeting interesting people. 
 
Well done BC - at last a voice of reason. 
 
I 100% agree with you. 
 
Maureen. 
x
 16 By Anthony, on 18-04-2008 15:21
I don’t think Intellectual Property infringement is the issue here. It just seems that Hemisphere went to a single source of ‘inspiration’ for the motif, roundel and colour scheme. The process couldn't have taken more than an afternoon. 
 
It just displayed a laziness and cynicism which compounds in the public’s mind that the exercise of branding is smoke and mirrors dolled up with marketing speak.  
 
We can all be a bit guilty of that at times. Hemisphere has just made it look so obvious.
 17 By Peter_H, on 18-04-2008 15:58
Surely it doesn't matter whether the idea takes 1 second or 1 year...as long as it's right? 
 
I imagine there may have been more than one route on the table at some point??? 
 
There's numerous examples of super simple, and highly succesful brand marques out there. And perhaps every now and then there'll be some similar outcomes to some similar briefs? 
 
BC touched on the cynicism in the production process, but whenever public sector work is presented it's gonna get a kicking regardless. 
 
Only the brave or fool-hardy want to touch work like this. I'm sure this agency doesn't fall into the latter category.
 18 By SWebb, on 18-04-2008 16:29
This is a very interesting case. This case should be sent into DesignWeek and open up a much larger debate on the line between inspiration/influence and plagiarism. What do you think?
 19 By Simon Wharton website, on 18-04-2008 18:50
Outraged of Tunbridge Wells has just made us cry. 
Funniest thread on How Do to date
 20 By Rachel P, on 18-04-2008 20:01
You’re right, It is a really fascinating case. Is it really plagiarism? More people should know about this and open up the debate and decide. DesignWeek needs to know the north exists! We should send the web address of this page to Lynda Relph-Knight at DesignWeek. lyndark@centaur.co.uk.
 21 By Diane website, on 19-04-2008 12:22
I think the new logo is very interesting. I'm not suprised they chose to use an O. After all when neighbouring Manchester got a new logo they picked a lovely M. 
 
I'd not made the connection with metrolink as we're not getting the metrolink in Oldham unless we get a M60 congestion charge.
 22 By Oldham for President! website, on 24-04-2008 16:56
www.barackobama.com...
 23 By just being frank, on 25-04-2008 06:36
it looks just like an icon on my iphone but then so does everything these days???

Add your comment
Name
Email (optional)
Website (optional)
Comment

Anti-spam question (required): 6 + 2 =

 
< Previous story   Next story >


Today's other news
How-Do weekly Wrap - 25 July 2008 - Sean Marley
Hard cheese and more for Brazen
Wish FM for a better future
New BBC base designed by ID:SR
Decade for Bird and Feld
Tula relaunch with 999 Design
FC Business media partner for Northwest Football Awards
Lambrini takes to TV with BJL
Stan wins BroomeJenkins account
Ian Singleton to be news editor at the Lancs Telegraph
All Out Productions celebrates new website with new commissions
Three former senior Oakbase staffers launch new agency Klebenleiben
 
 
 
 
Most read in the last three days
Future of The Darrener uncertain after owner banned from Darwen FC
Newsquest digital staffer Rob Woods dies after crash
Former journo Jason Green joins Oakbase
Online soap opera Spinning Jenny goes live with daily show
New series of Dragons' Den attracts the show's fourth biggest audience
jwt move quickly to replace McKay with Scott as head of digital
LOVE to redesign travel company Carrier's website
Three former senior Oakbase staffers launch new agency Klebenleiben
Jonathan Brown new northern correspondent of The Independent
The BusinessDesk.com exploring options for a North West launch
Featured articles
 A first for the North West - How-Do's Top 100 Marketers. These leading professionals help drive the creation and generation of prosperity in the region. READ
 The North West’s media folk who wield the greatest combination of influence, power and employment, primarily in the region but also, in many cases, well beyond. READ
 Working with Hill Dickinson, the CBI and the CIM, How-Do reveals the region’s leading brands across a variety of business sectors and categories. READ
 
Contact us now
The How-Do poll
Have you seen evidence of a downturn as yet in your business?
 
Latest comments
Peter Pickering: The new series is certainly not an improvement, and the half-hearted attemp... READ
Matty: To me it looks like a wannabe Hello but without the substance - and readers... READ
Dogghouse: Am I the only person who thought the new series was dreadful? Given that e... READ
Minnie: Interesting strategy. With the credit crunch looming are companies really g... READ
Jonathan Wilde: Mr Osato - I share your disbelief!!! READ
Mr Osato: What? Hate to post this on a story which should be a tribute to the late Mr... READ
How-Do RSS Feed

Track How-Do headlines in your RSS reader:

RSS feed

View all of our feeds.

Who's online?
We have 35 guests and 2 members online
Front Page | How-Do TV | News | Jobs | Features | Comment | Rumours | How do they do | How did they do | Expertise | Blogs | Education | About | Login
NEWS BY SECTOR | Publishing | Broadcasting | Marketing Services | Digital Media | Other Media | The Wrap | Polls | How-Do Awards
 
UKFast - managed dedicated server specialist