News, opinion and resources for the North West media industry Subscribe to our RSS feed
Front Page | Jobs | News | How-Do TV | Features | Comment | Rumours | How do they do | How did they do | Blogs | About | Ad Rates | Login | MarketPlace
NEWS BY SECTOR | Publishing | Broadcasting | Marketing Services | Digital Media | Other Media | The Wrap | Polls | How-Do Awards | How-Do Events

How-Do weekly Wrap - 31 July 2009 - John Williams | Print |  Email to a friend
Friday, 31 July 2009

Welcome to the weekly Wrap from How-Do - media news for the North West.

The Wrap's guest editor this week is John Williams.

 It’s difficult to resist the “too many twits make a twat” comment from Dave in a week when nearly every (I exaggerate) story on How-Do is concerned with the latest, and I suspect, short lived communication sensation, Twitter.

Quite what it is that makes people want to discuss the minutiae of their lives with complete strangers is something that mystifies me – and indeed we’re no exception to the rule of thumb which says we must all be Twits – or whatever.

Manchester Airport is the latest to get stuck in. As I write they tell me that they have Mango and FatFace stores now open in T1. This and the fact that the airport also currently has people apparently “flying away to escape the rain” are, I have to say, not true revelations for this time of year.

A man I don’t know called Gareth Holland confides that he is “sat in the executive lounge drinking Heineken” which is wonderful to know.

Reassuringly though, apparently new research has proved that almost half of the region’s leading brands and businesses “do not yet have a dedicated Twitter feed” which proves that the hard-earned reputation for Northern Good Sense still has some justification.

For those less sceptical than I am about the value of Twittering - I sort of think that if Stephen Fry is doing it I won’t – there are various excellent guides to how to make this work for you including Twitter for PR, Copyblogger and  and Chris Brogan.

I’m a complete gadget freak and a huge believer in new ways to get to our audiences – don’t get me started on how great the coming mobile phone transaction revolution is going to be - but, like every medium, content is king and I’m not going to trawl through the dross of people telling me they are in a bar to find out that an airport has people leaving in planes.

Just as it was fascinating, of course, to recently learn that Tangerine’s Vicki Lamb is “off to the gym” while her colleague Karen Adams is wondering what to make for tea but who really cares?

The most successful businessman I know well does not have an e-mail address and does all his communication by voice. When our offices get quiet I worry that people are hiding behind emails or Twittering when I’d rather they picked up the phone and talked to journalists.

John Williams is chairman of Mason Williams

Other stories on How-Do since last week's Wrap:

 
Something to add? Then leave a comment below or email us now.


Did you enjoy this article? Please share it!
Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!


Sponsored links:




  Comments (22)
RSS comments
 1 By flat earth syndrome, on 31-07-2009 10:18
Wow - I'd be pretty disturbed if a director of comms agency that I was associated with said he can't see the point of twitter, great job!
 2 By getagrip, on 31-07-2009 10:29
Sweet Jesus. Do you still do 80's style power lunches at San Carlo, broker deals 'on the golf course' and fax people? 
 
What a ridiculous view on a tool that is helping redefine how brands and consumers engage with each other. As a marketeer you should be completely clued up on how you use Twitter to gain insight and hear what interesting people have to say. It's about listening, interacting and learning. Yes, there is some benign stuff in there but that's what gives it warmth and makes it human.  
 
If I was a Mason Williams client (or in fact team member) I would be worried that the person leading my PR efforts didn't get it. In Twitter speak massive FAIL
 3 By Complete Twit, on 31-07-2009 10:37
yeh yeh...folks put a note in your diary for 1 August 2010 - "Check whether that thing called Twitter gets much use these days." Rest assured - it will be right up there with VHS recorders. You read it here first.
 4 By Nigel Sarbutts, on 31-07-2009 10:44
John, a glorious, grumpy old man rant and you are bang on about all the "I think I might have a cuppa" bollocks, but you need to leave the shallow end and head for deeper water. Try something like FTMediaNews for a while, it's really quite good stuff.
 5 By Regan, on 31-07-2009 10:53
Spot on John. 
 
Never met a t**t who didn't twitter.
 6 By Phil, on 31-07-2009 11:16
Excellent read, dont agree with all the fuss over twitter at the moment, nobody I know looks at companies/brands twitters. As a tool for celebrities to promote themselves to fans great but nothing else.
 7 By Captain Ludd, on 31-07-2009 11:23
Getagrip - don't tell me, you work in the 'digital department'.  
 
You guys sat around for years scratching your arses then suddenly up popped Twitter. Your wildest dreams were suddenly answered! You didn't have to do any real work - you could just sell your poor old client a Twitter 'solution' and be in the pub by noon talking about Dr Who and your latest high score.  
 
I'm with Complete Twit - Twitter is, largely, complete bollocks.
 8 By DevLifeRant website, on 31-07-2009 11:56
this is funny, you marketing guys really don't have a clue do you?
 9 By Rob Brown website, on 31-07-2009 12:12
Thoroughly enjoyable and I know you well enough to realise that you were throwing a grenade into the room. The resulting comment storm was clearly the result of quite deliberate provocation. Twitter is both full of crap and also the most exciting new communications platform in over a decade. I’m also sure that you don’t do 80s power lunches any more …or you would have sent me a DM on twitter to confirm the lunch you suggested a few weeks ago….
 10 By Rocky, on 31-07-2009 12:14
The worry is most people are either in denial or totally infactuated with Twitter. 
Keep things in proportion. 
The smart money says it's a fad. A massive one, that we should all understand and exploit for all the right reasons, but a fad all the same.
 11 By Steve Downes website, on 31-07-2009 13:19
Entertaining Wrap John. Maybe yiou should've shoved your tongue in your cheek in the photo!  
Can see that many still don't get the difference between social media marketing and social media networking. 
Fancy lunch at San Carlo?
 12 By Tony Murray, on 31-07-2009 15:53
Can I just say that, as many Internet applications are still blocked here in the PRC due to bands of Twitter-friendly rebels in the west of the country, I.. 
a) Have not been to the gym 
b) Have had noodles for dinner (again) 
c) Am now having a beer. 
d) Think its very unfair to take the piss out of John for his 80s power lunches. He only looks mid 70s in his pic
 13 By Simon Wharton website, on 31-07-2009 16:12
Tongue in cheek may be but symptomatic of the majority of PR agencies clearly not understanding the reach of the full range of digital channels that the audience is already engaged with. If you are a brand needing support, maybe you are going to make a purchase decision based on who addresses where opinions are being formed, and can interact with that channel
 14 By Janine Watson, on 31-07-2009 16:36
Crikey John good to see you in Paxman-style mode stirring the debate. I thought I got it hard being labelled Germaine when I criticised the How-Do Honey awards. (Remember those boys? Back in the retro-days of 200errrm-oh-yes-2008. Shameful!) Anyway, I too will lunch with you John in San Carlos anytime. Tweet dreams, J. x.
 15 By Gordo website, on 31-07-2009 16:43
Gordo, he loves them power lunches he does. He does a bit of that Twittering as well (GordoManchester, read it and weep, especially the ones from his lavatory at 07:45 and 16.30, it depends on whether it was Guinness or Red Wine the day before). Now, the jury is out on Twitter for Gordo, but he does have two hundred and eighty two and a half PR Girlies following him. The half, by the way, is Mike Perls. Not in touch with his feminine side like Gordo, is our Mike...
 16 By Debz H, on 03-08-2009 16:58
John what a speech agreed twitter is just so NOT . Casius Clay unique quote " I so fast I turned off my light in my hotel room and I was in bed before it went dark" now thats communication fast, to the point and delivers
 17 By Jane website, on 03-08-2009 05:46
Like any advance it is always best to master it rather than to be a slave to it.
 18 By Gez website, on 03-08-2009 11:10
New Fat Face and Mango stores in T1 you say? How did you hear about that? And how did Manchester Airport PR team manage to get that piece of information in the How-Do weekly wrap? Surely several lengthy phone calls to journalists would be required? 
 
Or maybe a 5 second tweet would do it.
 19 By Paul Fabretti website, on 03-08-2009 12:55
@gez totally useless indeed. 
 
To know that there is somewhere at the Airport I could buy some last-minute forgotten items and maybe even save a few quid too is pointless - and to know about this in a way that is convenient for me is a total waste of time. This social networking stuff will never catch on... 
 
It's difficult not to criticise the original twaddle by falling into the "Tongue in cheek" safety net with which it was written (to allow the author an "i'm only joking" escape route should people rightly criticise his article), but the fact that that John feels that this subject alone is even worth discussing now demonstrates a woeful lack of touch with "now". 
 
It's all well and good when something is emerging or new and a bit of a gimmick, but to do so a good year after it has hit the mainstream is pretty embarrassing really.
 20 By flat earth syndrome website, on 03-08-2009 15:26
Here's a link to why Twitter is really rather handy for PR. (see home icon) 
 
And no, my tongue isn't in any cheeks. Bravo to the last 2 comments
 21 By Al Mackin website, on 03-08-2009 19:43
The costs of setting up and maintaining a twitter account are neglible, which is why it's a logical commercial decision. There are plenty of reasons to trial it, and equally to never use it again, but for some companies it's a natural way to brand-build and pick up some traffic at the same time.
 22 By Gez website, on 04-08-2009 15:45
I have to say once again I hold no value in the comments against John Williams by anonymous users. If you disagree, have enough conviction in your opinion to state who you are. 
 
While I disagree with some comments in this wrap (tongue in cheek or not), the sniping on this and other articles is unjustified.

Add your comment
Name
Email (optional)
Website (optional)
Comment

Email me when someone else comments
Anti-spam question (required): 7 + 8 =

 
< Previous story   Next story >


Beyond 2010
How-Do's Alternative Wrap
Today's other news
Master Google with UK first at Salford Business School
Dinosaur shows what Manchester's made of
Citrus Suite develops Project Canvas interaction
5 Live launches Northern Development Fund
New media meets old as StuckOn gets CSAhell on the radio
True North promotes Holburne Museum reopening
APS Group wins Family Investments contract
Manchester Matters launches on Monday
MEN deal aids Trinity Mirror performance
Ahoy Creative gives parents a break with Away Without The Kids
Madhouse promotes K3 with naked employees
MOSI turns to London agency kin for interactive gallery
Acrobat thinks Victorian for Gourmet Candy Company brief
Mando Group Labs officially launches
Charles Lawson returns for Coronation Street play
JudgeGill unveils Harrods department for WWRD
 
 
 How-Do Events - click here    How-Do Events - click here
 
 
 
Most read in the last three days
No move to Salford yet for Peter Salmon (Updated)
Brazen's Robbie Platt joins Weber Shandwick
Why is video taking over the world?
Nickelodeon opens £10m theme park in Blackpool
Rippleffect saddles up for British Horseracing campaign
Paver Smith income up despite public sector hit
Madhouse promotes K3 with naked employees
Gorillaz hit the App store courtesy of Matmi
Stage 9 on track for Preston Trams
Ideal returns to BBC Three
Featured articles
The most comprehensive ever review and assessment of the top communicators and marketers working in public services in the North West: the Public Sector 100. READ
Media 100
The North West’s top marketing folk who collectively control marketing expenditure in excess of £500m and whose endeavours help sustain tens of thousands of jobs. READ
2009media100 The full listing of How-Do's Media 100. The 2009 list in its entirety, offers the definitive compilation of the most influential and powerful media, creative and digital folk based in the North West. READ
 
Contact us now
The How-Do poll
How can traditional publishing firms make money online?
 
Latest comments
Cath: These people should not be allowed to take these roles unless they are 100%... READ
Radio Caroline: But the pettiness is what makes people come to the site. Everyone loves to ... READ
Lorna Kay: The highly inflammatory article by Paul Revoir on page 11 of to-day's Daily... READ
Enough: Also Anonymouse - get down off your high-horse. You threw your two penneth ... READ
Mrs Ackroyd: What a load of numpties GMG are. You wouldn't want them running anything i... READ
Brian: Why do marketeers use 'inspired by' when the word 'evokes' is more believab... READ
How-Do RSS/Twitter

Track How-Do headlines in your RSS reader:

RSS feed

View all of our feeds.

Follow How-Do on Twitter:

How-Do Twitter
 
 
 Media City UK
 
 


 
 
 
Front Page | Jobs | News | How-Do TV | Features | Comment | Rumours | How do they do | How did they do | Blogs | About | Ad Rates | Login | MarketPlace
NEWS BY SECTOR | Publishing | Broadcasting | Marketing Services | Digital Media | Other Media | The Wrap | Polls | How-Do Awards | How-Do Events
 
UKFast - managed dedicated server specialist